Winning VA Compensation for Agent Orange Exposure

80

By Pink Mingos

Agent Orange

During the Vietnam War, (1962-1971), the U.S. used an Herbacide called "Agent Orange" as part of a defoliant program. Using aircraft such as the UH-1D helicopter, more than 21,000,000 gallons of Agent Orange (given this name because of the bright orange 55 gallon drums it was shipped in) was sprayed over South Vietnam.

The dioxins produced as contaminants during the production of Agent Orange are the cause of known health problems resulting from those exposed to the herbacide.

What was the purpose of Agent Orange?

By 1971, 20% of South Vietnam's jungles had been sprayed with AO.

The first objective was to reduce the foilage that provided Communist forces a cover and to deny them the use of crops needed for food.

The second objective was to clear the areas around base perimeters and to drive civilians into the controlled areas.

In the post war era, more than 400,000 deaths and disabilities were contributed to AO exposure, and over 500,000 children born with birth defects.

Long Term Effects of Agent Orange Exposure

 Among the many medical conditions that AO exposure has been found to cause in the individual (cancer, skin diseases, Diabetes Mellitus (Type II)), it has been found that children of exposed victims have a higher rate of birth defects, most commonly Spina Bifida.  In 1997, the Veteran's Benefits act (of same year) granted benefits for children of Vietnam Veterans who were sufffering from spina bifida.

How VA Compensation Works

Although each case is different and treated as such, there are only a few basic requirements to qualify for VA Compensation:

(1) Have a service connected disability, and
(2) Have been discharged under honorable conditions.

#2 is easily proven one way or another.

Most often the service member has the most obstacles proving that the disability they have is service connected, unless of couse it is clearly documented in their service medical records.

Let's look at a couple of examples:

Service member was injured while on active duty (either during war time or peace time, doesn't matter), say for example they were at the firing range and their weapon misfired which resulted in injury. This accident, along with medical treatment will be documented in their military medical records.

But what about a situation (such as in my case) where a condition happend while on active duty that did not result in disability until years later?

(I was diagnosed with Meniere's Disease during my second year of a tour of duty overseas. This is well documented in my medical records, both military and a local Neurosurgeon there in Holland. It wasn't until recent years the long term damage (22 years after diagnosis) forced me to stop working. I had no problem proving my current disability was directly service connected).

If there is no documentation in your service medical records of either the current condition, or a condition that is known to cause your current condition, then it can be a very long drawn out process with your goal being to prove the service connection.

Agent Orange as a "Presumptive Service Connection"

Unlike the Social Security Disability Administration, the VA works to help the veteran receive benefits due to them.

Working in the veteran's favor, the VA has developed a certain group of "Presumptive Service Connected" conditions such a "Agent Orange Exposure".

What this means is that a veteran who has devloped certain medical condition(s) (I will use Diabetes (Type II) as an example) well after leaving active duty, may be given the benefit of doubt that it is a service connected/compensatable condition even if there was never any documentation of Diabetes (Type II) in their service medical records.

Since certain medical conditions have been found to be a result of Agent Orange Exposure, a service member who began experiencing any of these conditions after leaving active duty can be eligble for VA Compensation for the condition through a Presumptive Service Connection if service records show that the service member served in the Republic of Vietnam during the years of 1/9/62 - 5/7/75.

Presumptive Service Connection:

" VA presumes that specific disabilities diagnosed in certain veterans were caused by their military service. VA does this because of the unique circumstances of their military service. If one of these conditions is diagnosed in a veteran in one of these groups, VA presumes that the circumstances of his/her service caused the condition, and disability compensation can be awarded. "

The Agent Orange Presumptive Group:

Vietnam Veterans

(Exposed to

Agent Orange)

Served in the Republic of Vietnam between 1/9/62 and 5/7/75:

(These conditions are presumed to be service connected for Vietnam Veterans who served in the the above location during the specific time frame)

· chloracne or other acneform disease similar to chloracne*

· porphyria cutanea tarda*

· soft-tissue sarcoma (other than osteosarcoma, chondrosarcoma, Kaposi's sarcoma or mesothelioma)

· Hodgkin's disease

· multiple myeloma

· respiratory cancers (lung, bronchus, larynx, trachea)

· non-Hodgkin's lymphoma

· prostate cancer

· acute and subacute peripheral neuropathy*

· type 2 diabetes

· chronic lymphocytic leukemia

*Must become manifest to a degree of 10 percent or more within a year after the last date on which the veteran was exposed to an herbicide agent during active military, naval, or air service.

Don't Take No For An Answer

If you or anyone you know is a veteran of the Vietnam war and has any of the listed medical conditions (see links below), and have been denied VA Compensation, please don't give up. I have seen all too often where a service member files for compensation, supported by little information only to receive a denial and leave it at that.

While the VA really is a veteran's friend, they have literally thousands of claims to process and can not take time in most cases to put 2 and 2 together for the service member. If the service member only states "I am filing for compensation because I have diabetes", the claims processor may very well deny it and move on to the next claim simply because they can only approve if given supported information. They can not (in most cases) research the service member's military background.

This is why it is important to back up your claim with helpful information/documentation.

That same service member would have met with more positive results had their claim included:

"I am filing for VA compensation based on the fact that I have Diabetes (Type II), which is associated with exposure to Agent Orange. As my service records show, I served in South Vietnam during 1965 -1967 during the use of AO. I am enclosing medical records from my family physician confirming my medical condition. My request for VA Compensation for Diabetes (Type II) is supported by the Presumptive Service Connection".

You've now given them information supporting your claim, possibly making it easier for them to reference and make a more favorable choice.

I would also strongly suggest that the service member seek the advice and help of their county VA Representative who is trained in filing claims and providing support and assistance to all veterans. They have the experience to make sure your claim includes necessary information before filing. Their service is free and you are not limited to your county, you may seek out any VA representative or local VFW Volunteer with experience in helping with this sort of thing!

http://www.vba.va.gov/bln/21/benefits/Herbicide/

http://www.vba.va.gov/bln/21/Benefits/Herbicide/AOno1.htm

The 5 Most Recent Hubs from Pink Mingos

Comments

livewithrichard profile image

livewithrichard Level 1 Commenter 2 years ago

Great article, though I hear there are still something like 300,000 Navy and Coast Guard veterans that are still being denied presumption of exposure to Agent Orange dioxin because their exposure came while serving offshore Vietnam. Just this past January, the Supreme Court decided hot to hear a case on this. However there are a couple congressman that are trying to remedy this through legislation. Sadly, I don't understand what the hold up is. I can understand the costs but denying a Veteran that served this country in a time of war is pathetic, to say the least.

Pink Mingos profile image

Pink Mingos Hub Author 2 years ago

The sad thing is that most will (or have not) lived to see the day when they will win a decision to classify them as a presumptive group.

That particular ruling did not mean that a service member who was serving offshore Vietnam could *not* get VA compensation for AO, just that it didn't automatically mean that if the service person in that group developed one of the listed medical conditions that it was caused by the AO.

Unfortunately, each of those service members would have to file claims with a little more supporting information. For example, spending any time at all on mainland, no matter how brief would place them in the already established AO presumptive group that served on mainland.

See "Who can get benefits" in the link below:

http://www.vba.va.gov/bln/21/benefits/herbicide/AO

" Under the law, veterans who served in Vietnam between 1962 and 1975 (including those who visited Vietnam even briefly), and who have a disease that VA recognizes as being associated with Agent Orange, are presumed to have been exposed to Agent Orange. "

If they can even prove they stepped off the ship for any amount of time in the affected area, it would place them in the already established group that served on mainland.

I suppose government refuses to recognize them as a group as likely to have been sprayed since only the jungle/mainland was sprayed, but winds carry that stuff ya know? That and again, simply getting off the ship and tracking it back onboard to the others, yeah I can see that.

livewithrichard profile image

livewithrichard Level 1 Commenter 2 years ago

My step father has been trying for years now. He already has some VA disability but he keeps getting denied for his diabetes. He was on ship and in the Vietnam theater but never stepped foot on land. Sad thing is, he was also on ship during the first Gulf War (the USS Wisconsin)when the gas alarms went off at least once a week, but no luck in claiming that yet either. I have heard that a lot of the Wisconsin crew have developed some type of chronic disorder.

Pink Mingos profile image

Pink Mingos Hub Author 2 years ago

I have a link for you, Richard.

Not sure how much help this particular thread will be since it discusses ways to prove you stepped foot on mainland, but the forum is full of some really great vets helping each other out and there are a LOT of vietnam vets there, even those that were on Navy ships.

If anybody can give advice on possibilities, it would be them.

BTW, tell your step dad I said "thanks!"

http://vets.yuku.com/topic/33990

Brian 18 months ago

My wifes father served in NAM as my dad did too. My wife's father collects on AO benefits... She was born with one of ears not functional.... Is she entitled to benefits? My father has never checked in to any VA options for serving, I am wondering if he is entitled to any compensation now that he is retired.. not military though...

bkhorban@sbcglobal.net

Pink Mingos profile image

Pink Mingos Hub Author 17 months ago

Hi Brian.

There are situations where children of the Vietnam Vet receive benefits, how ever only a few medical conditions are considered automatic.

I would say your wife has a good chance of receiving some type of benefits if it can be proven that her condition is a direct result of the AO exposure to your father in law. Either way, there is nothing stopping her from applying for compensation. Good luck!

David "Doc" Andersen 2 months ago

Great stuff, great writing (my opinion, anyway; now a retired editor, etc., etc.; wordsmithing foundation). Thank you. Wife and I are now preparing to file for D Type II, which I have. A buddy in Vietnam, now dead, I think, stayed "in," retiring as an intelligence officer of some kind. Several years ago he finally tracked me down; just wanted to say Thank You for saving his life in a terrific dying-in-river firefight. Talked a few times. Couldn't send me the Confidential reports, which, he said, showed that our fighting unit, Fox 2/3 (I was attached as Navy Hospital Corpsman--Marines medic) operated, in '68 and '69, in areas always thick in spraying and respraying, in areas of the DMZ and northern I Corps. Wow, I almost can't believe it: almost my entire message erased because I fell off in slumber--extreme narcolepsy, from sleep apnea, from AO, as my brain melts from AO. Oh, well: enough anyway. Best of luck to you, there. A few years ago I was forced to retire early, at 61, because of PTSD symptoms, and diabetes-related stuff. I now live in southern AZ, desert ground haunted by Apaches and other Native American groups--soon to join a clutch of dispossessed people. Could it really be: the government, the country I loved and fought for, and lived beyond the fighting only because of repeated miracles, poisoned me, leaving me in a position where, after 33 years of marriage, my wife will be widowed much earlier than she should be? PS: ever the Marines trained warrior "medic," vengeful, I just wish I could see Cheney and Bush go with me. (This is not a threat, agent assholes, just a nonactionable wish.) Bush chose to snort coke and guzzle whiskey instead of even attending his reserve meetings, let alone put his Boots on the Ground, and Cheney now writes with pride about the fact that he obtained five deferments from service during the V war, but, hey, he considers that his bureaucratic wrangling, climbing ladders within the DC world, as more important than volunteering, or being drafted. Real hero types who, to get an old man's hard on, put men and women On the Ground in Iraq. What was that for, again? Was it like Vietnam, where they never had the balls to be? never had the balls to lay on deadly-hostile, AO-poisoned ground, trying to sleep with one eye open? Farewell: I am honored and proud to have served with the Marines in combat; but starting in Vietnam, the fat and sassy, corrupted country lost its way, sacrificing my friends and, now, me, in the process. Wow, what a world: we've all become, now, figuratively speaking, Rush Limbaughs, fat, greedy, smoking a long, expensive stogy while spewing hate--as in, "sluts" spending lots on "the pill" to have lots of sex; what, the dummy thinks they're like Viagra, and every time you indulge you have to take one; there's brilliance for ya, so lel's all tune to learn more; or, oh, what? he's losing all his advertisers, O what a shame, maybe he'll gain comfort from one of his four wives, all child-barren; what, was he taking them?--like Cheney and Bush. Let's put 'em all in a bag and drop them into a S. Am. country, like me and others into Vietnam. Then they can try to follow Bush's advice, when asked by one S. Am. president how best to make money for his his country: "War," he said haughtily, even angrily. "Don't you know: war is where it's at!!! Get a war going! It's the best way to get a bunch of money flowing into the hands of the right people in your country, and they'll create jobs, right? Seriously, get a war going--SOON!!" (How the hell do I know? I was also a reporter. Good luck, fellow countrymen. Make sure the sons and daughters of politicians go to war, too.)

lynn 2 months ago

my husband served in thiland at nakon phong was denied benifits because duties didnt include perimiter.Am trying to find any air flight information as to when he left and where the stop offs were if i can prove that stop off was in vietnan on route.He passed away from mupliple mylemoa in dec 7 2010.any help appreciated.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working